Алена Шлегель

23 окт 2022 23.10.2022

Отказ в привлечении к субсидиарной ответственности

Отказ в привлечении к субсидиарной ответственности. Задолженность по выплате действительной стоимости доли участнику Общества не является основанием для привлечения к ответственности.
ПОСТАНОВЛЕНИЕ АС ЗСО от 18.10.2022 по делу No А03-2801/2021
Выводы первой инстанции:
https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/dec23679-9a93-44a9-b5b9-aef60e3940a2/6e6edf0c-1c8c-4379-8af1-165f98fec6dd/A03-2801-2021_20221018_Postanovlenie_kassacionnoj_instancii.pdf?isAddStamp=True
Выводы кассации:
https://kad.arbitr.ru/Document/Pdf/dec23679-9a93-44a9-b5b9-aef60e3940a2/99c32be6-5b4d-4b8f-a075-113837c07e74/A03-2801-2021_20220307_Reshenija_i_postanovlenija.pdf?isAddStamp=True
Краткая позиция суда:
✅Права участника не нарушены
✅Выплата доли привела бы к признаку неплатежеспособности.
✅Кроме того, при наличии обязательств перед участником инициирование процедуры банкротства общества также не привело бы к восстановлению прав истца, поскольку требование о взыскании действительной стоимости доли не подлежит включению в реестр требований кредиторов.

0 показов

19 открытий

0

Комментарии

Написать комментарий...

-3 комментариев

Раскрывать всегда

[{"id":1,"label":"Header, 100%x250: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","auto_reload":true,"adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"ezfl"}},"distribution":"top-desktop"},{"id":2,"label":"Header, 1200x400\/600: M","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","auto_reload":true,"adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"ezfn"}},"distribution":"top-mobile"},{"id":4,"label":"Article Branding top","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"cfovx","p2":"glug"}}},{"id":5,"label":"300x600: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"ezfk"}},"distribution":"right-sidebar"},{"id":6,"label":"Above the Comments: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"h","ps":"bugf","p2":"ffyh"}},"distribution":"before-comments-desktop","analytics":"AdfoxRecount \u2014 1020 \u2014 Show"},{"id":7,"label":"Above the Comments: M","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"bwkpg","p2":"fjxb"}},"distribution":"before-comments-mobile"},{"id":12,"label":"Topbar button: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"bscsh","p2":"fdhx"}}},{"id":13,"label":"In Article: M","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"h","ps":"bugf","p2":"flvn"}},"analytics":"AdfoxRecount \u2014 300 \u2014 Show"},{"id":15,"label":"In-Feed Teaser: DM","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop","tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"byudx","p2":"ftjf"}}},{"id":16,"label":"Topbar button: M","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"byzqf","p2":"ftwx"}}},{"id":17,"label":"Stratum: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","auto_reload":true,"adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"fzvb"}}},{"id":18,"label":"Stratum: M","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","auto_reload":true,"adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"fzvc"}}},{"id":19,"label":"Under the News Teaser: DM","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop","tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","auto_reload":true,"adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"cbltd","p2":"gazs"}}},{"id":20,"label":"Leftbar button: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"p1":"cgxmr","p2":"gnwc"}}},{"id":21,"label":"Header Microteaser: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"gtjk"}}},{"id":23,"label":"In Article: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"hiig"}}},{"id":26,"label":"For test: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"icbj"}}},{"id":27,"label":"For test: M","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"icbn"}}},{"id":28,"label":"For test: DM","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop","tablet","phone"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"icbo"}}},{"id":31,"label":"300x600 screen 2: D","provider":"adfox","adaptive":["desktop"],"adfox_method":"createAdaptive","adfox":{"ownerId":228129,"params":{"pp":"g","ps":"bugf","p2":"fizc"}}}]